Top 10 Best MTG Cards for Multiplayer

Today we’ll talk about the best MTG cards for Multiplayer formats. While these cards are not necessarily bad in a 1 vs 1 match, they become insanely strong when you have more opponents.

So let’s take a look at which cards you need to beat multiple opponents.

#10 Expropriate

Best Blue Multiplayer Cards MTG Expropriate

Expropriate is a sweet card. At worst you’ll get one extra turn and steal one permanent from everybody. Sometimes your opponent will rather give you an extra turn then theirs best permanent, in which case you’ll also be happy. There’s a lot you can do in two (or more!) extra turns.

Of course the biggest problem with Expropriate is its mana cost. If your playgroup plays more competitive decks and you don’t reach 9 mana very often, it’s sadly not the right card for you.

#9 Tempt with Discovery

Top 10 MTG Cards for Multiplayer Tempt with Discovery

If you like taking advantage of your greedy opponents, you can tempt them with discovery. At worst, this will go get you any one land and put it on the battlefield untapped. Now depending on your play group you could get a whole bunch of lands in play.

In our experience players often decide to get a land, therefore making Tempt with Discovery one of the best 4-mana ramp spells for Multiplayer.

#8 Blasphemous Act

Best MTG Cards for Multiplayer Blasphemous Act

When do you want to destroy all creatures? Usually, when there are lots of creatures in play – and that’s when Blasphemous Act is at its best. It often costs just one mana!

It will mostly do the same job as Damnation for less mana. Besides that, it’s also more budget friendly. Since the board is often crowded in Multiplayer, this is a great addition to any red deck.

#7 Syr Konrad, the Grim

Best MTG Cards for More Than Two Players Syr Konrad the Grim

The newest card on the list is an uncommon from Throne of Eldraine. This black knight was already insane in draft, but now he’s ready to wreck some Multiplayer games.

Let’s break down that wall of text. Konrad deals 1 damage to each opponent whenever:

  • another creatures dies
  • a creature is put into a graveyard from anywhere (other than the battlefield)
  • a creature leaves your graveyard

That’s a ton of damage in a regular Multiplayer game. Konrad does finish the game quickly.

#6 Blatant Thievery

Top 10 MTG Cards for Multiplayer Blatant Thievery

Blantant Thievery is one of those cards that go from medium to totally busted, when you increase the number of your opponents.

For seven mana Agent of Treachery is already a fine deal in formats like Commander. Of course, that’s a creature and you can blink it and abuse in a number of different ways. However, once you add just the second opponent to the mix, Thievery becomes a better card.

Imagine playing this card against three or more opponents. It’s devastating and probably wins you the game on the spot. It’s a great addition to any blue deck meant for Multiplayer.

Blatant Thievery was recently reprinted in Explorers of Ixalan, special board game. Think Settlers of Catan + Magic the Gathering. If you like board games and want Blatant Thievery anyways, it might be a good product for you. You can check Explorers of Ixalan on Amazon.

#5 Smothering Tithe

White ramp! It’s a white ramp and a good one at that. We don’t see many white cards like this anymore. Since its printing in Guilds of Ravnica (2018), Smothering Tithe has become a staple and certainly one of the best MTG cards for Multiplayer.

Don’t forget that the trigger doesn’t only happen in their draw steps, it happens every time they draw a card! Therefore it’s great against decks that draw lots of cards.

#4 Rhystic Study

Best MTG Cards for Multiplayer Rhystic Study

Blessed are the players, who didn’t hear the words “Did you pay the one?” over and over again. Rhystic Study is both incredibly good and incredibly annoying in Multiplayer.

Getting a Treasure token from Smothering Tithe is fine, but drawing a card is on another level. Not to mention, it triggers every time an opponent casts a spell. One mana might seems like a low cost, but it adds up so quickly.

That’s particularly true in a Multiplayer games. Your opponents are constantly casting spells and you’re constantly drawing cards – since they just can’t afford to pay one additional mana over and over again.

You should definitely play Rhystic Study, if you don’t mind annoying your opponents.

#3 Prophet of Kruphix

Best MTG Cards for Multiplayer Prophet of Kruphix

More players, more untap staps. More untap steps, more mana. More mana, more unfair things to do. You get the gist.

Prophet of Kruphix is so good that it’s banned in Commander. That fact doesn’t need to stop you from trying in in casual 60-card Multiplayer decks. Just make sure your deck isn’t too strong, then it becomes a bit boring for the rest of the table.

Anyways it definitely deserves a spot on our Top 10 Best MTG Cards for Multiplayer list.

#2 The Primordial Cycle

For the second place, we’re actually cheating a little. We put a cycle of five cards here. It’ll certainly feel like cheating when you cast one of them against multiple opponents – they’re just so strong. Just make sure, you won’t play the Sylvan Primordial in Commander – it’s banned and that would be actual cheating.

Luminate Primordial

Luminate Primordial Cycle

As usual, the white card is the worst in the cycle. For seven mana you get to exile one creature per opponent. Useful, but could do better. However, the rest of Primordials are all pretty powerful.

Diluvian Primordial

Diluvian Primordial Cycle

Blue Primordial’s power ranges from fine to broken, depending on which instants and sorceries your opponents are playing. Consider what you’ll play against before putting Diluvian Primordial in your deck.

Sepulchral Primordial

Sepulchral Primordial Cycle

Sepulchral Primordial isn’t messing around. You get one creature from each opponent’s graveyard. It goes without saying that more opponents you have, the better Sepulchral Primordial is. In Multiplayer it’s basically a whole army in one card.

Molten Primordial

Molten Primordial Cycle

Steal a creature from everyone and smash! You’ll be able to take out at least one opponent. Make sure that you have some sort of sacrifice outlet in your deck if you’re playing Molten Primordial, so your opponents won’t get their creatures back.

Sylvan Primordial

Sylvan Primordial Cycle

The best Primordial is most certainly the green one. Not only does it destroy one noncreature permanent per opponent, there’s more upside. You get to search your library for a Forest card (not only basic Forest) for each permanent destroyed this way. It’s so good it got banned in Commander.

#1 Torment of Hailfire

Best MTG Cards for Multiplayer Torment of Hailfire

Finally, we’ve reached the best of the best MTG cards for Multiplayer – Torment of Hailfire.

At first sight it might seem like a durdly card, but it’s actual text is: “Do you have a lot of mana? Then win the game.” This card does absurdly well in the late game and it affects every opponent. It’s probably the single best win condition in Multiplayer games.

The only problem with Torment is that it isn’t very good in the early game, but then again – which finisher is?

Torment of Hailfire is certainly pretty popular, as its price tag suggests. You can check its price on Amazon.

Honorable Mentions

There are so many good cards that get even better in Multiplayer. There’s no way that we could put all of them in our Top 10. So here are some strong cards that just missed our list:

Do you feel like we missed something good? That’s certainly possible, so share your best MTG cards for Multiplayer in the comments bellow.

Playing On

If you enjoy Magic the Gathering trivia, we have more Top 10 lists for you. Check out the following:

Make sure that you won’t miss another cool MTG article or spoiler and follow us on Facebook or Instagram. We’ll be happy to have you.

Until next time, may you beat all of your opponents.

2 thoughts on “Top 10 Best MTG Cards for Multiplayer”

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.