What’s up citizen? Welcome to our Spider-Man Draft Tier List. (Or to our Through the Omenpaths Draft Tier List, if you’re playing online.) This article can be used as a companion to Spider-Man Draft Guide. In that one, you’ll find all the big picture stuff, but here we’re going into specifics.
Below you’ll find grades for every Spider-Man card, based on their power level for draft. We’ll get to them in a second, but before that — let’s check what each grade means.
UPDATE: This article got an update on October 2nd, 2025 — after we drafted the set for around ten days. Thus, you can expect the grades to be fairly accurate. While some minor adjustments might be made in the future, there shouldn’t be anything drastically different.
Spider-Man Draft Tier List – Legend
Included examples are from the previous set, Edge of Eternities.
- A: The best bombs, cards that can win the game on their own. (Elegy Acolyte, Ouroboroid)
- B: Solid cards, which can be reasons to draft their colors. (Monoist Circuit-Feeder, Station Monitor)
- C: Playable cards. You won’t mind playing them, if you’re already playing their colors. (Blooming Stinger, Lost in Space)
- D: Mediocre cards. If you end up playing them, something went wrong during the draft. (Kavaron Skywarden, Luxknight Breacher)
- F: Unplayable, niche cards. Usually meant for constructed formats. (Cosmogoyf, Loading Zone)
All grades (except F) can come with a “+” or a “-” symbol. As expected, B+ is a better grade than B, which is better than B-.
Spider-Man Draft Tier List
So, without further ado, here are the grades for each and every card you can find in the Spider-Man Play boosters.
In the second column you’ll find card names from MTG Arena and Magic Online. (Cards are mechanically the same, but they have different artwork and names.)
| White | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-Venom, Horrifying Healer | Verilax the Havenskin | C |
| Arachne, Psionic Weaver | Yera and Oski, Weaver and Guide | C+ |
| Aunt May | Zora, Spider Fancier | C+ |
| City Pigeon | City Pigeon | B- |
| Costume Closet | Costume Closet | C |
| Daily Bugle Reporters | Principled Referee | C+ |
| Flash Thompson, Spider-Fan | Basil, Cabaretti Loudmouth | B- |
| Friendly Neighborhood | Remarkable Readings | A- |
| Origin of Spider-Man | A Most Helpful Weaver | A- |
| Peter Parker // Amazing Spider-Man | Surris, Spidersilk Innovator | B+ |
| Rent Is Due | Confessor's Bindings | D |
| Selfless Police Captain | Crime-Scene Instructor | C |
| Silver Sable, Mercenary Leader | Generous Betty Wray | B- |
| Spectacular Spider-Man | Ademi of the Silkchutes | B |
| Spectacular Tactics | Spectacular Tactics | B- |
| Spider-Man, Web-Slinger | Darval, Whose Web Protects | C |
| Spider-UK | Sarn of the Silken Throne | C+ |
| Starling, Aerial Ally | Eztli of the Thousand Moons | D |
| Sudden Strike | Sudden Strike | C+ |
| Thwip! | Lively Leap | C |
| Web Up | Mothwing Shroud | B- |
| Web-Shooters | Archangler's Skyrod | F |
| Wild Pack Squad | Freestrider Aces | D+ |
| With Great Power... | Chosen by Valgavoth | F |
| Comeuppance* | Comeuppance | B+ |
| Leyline Binding* | Leyline Binding | C+ |
| Nine Lives* | Nine Lives | F |
| Path to Exile* | Path to Exile | B |
| Reprieve* | Reprieve | B |
| Rest in Peace* | Rest in Peace | F |
| Wedding Ring* | Wedding Ring | F |
| Black | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Agent Venom | Rhilex the Accursed | C+ |
| Alien Symbiosis | Aggressive Symbiosis | D- |
| Behold the Sinister Six! | Hex of Undeath | B+ |
| Black Cat, Cunning Thief | Wrench, Speedway Saboteur | A |
| Common Crook | Common Crook | C |
| The Death of Gwen Stacy | The House Grows Hungry | B- |
| Eddie Brock // Venom, Lethal Protector | Viggo, Enforcer of Ig's Crossing | C+ |
| Gwenom, Remorseless | Egrix the Bile Bulwark | B |
| Inner Demons Gangsters | Caldaia Brawlers | D |
| Merciless Enforcers | Merciless Enforcers | C+ |
| Morlun, Devourer of Spiders | Luis, Pompous Pillager | A+ |
| Parker Luck | Duskmourn's Claim | F |
| Prison Break | Prison Break | D+ |
| Risky Research | Clandestine Work | D+ |
| Sandman's Quicksand | Miasmic Mist | D |
| Scorpion, Seething Striker | Scorvus Ames, Crimelord | C- |
| Scorpion's Sting | Scorpion's Sting | B- |
| The Soul Stone | The Terminus of Return | C |
| Spider-Man Noir | Kroble, Envoy of the Bog | C+ |
| The Spot's Portal | Remorseless Coup | B- |
| Swarm, Being of Bees | Wekhdu, Midnight Hunter | C |
| Tombstone, Career Criminal | Nill, Vessel of Valgavoth | C+ |
| Venom, Evil Unleashed | Tethex, Gift of Malice | C |
| Venomized Cat | Bane-Marked Leonin | C |
| Venom's Hunger | Damning Caress | B- |
| Villainous Wrath | Villainous Wrath | A- |
| Feed the Swarm* | Feed the Swarm | B- |
| Hex* | Hex | D |
| Infernal Grasp* | Infernal Grasp | B |
| Opposition Agent* | Opposition Agent | C- |
| Reanimate* | Reanimate | B+ |
| Saw in Half* | Saw in Half | C- |
| Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon* | Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon | B |
| Green | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Damage Control Crew | Selesnya Archivist | B |
| Ezekiel Sims, Spider-Totem | Orris, Last of the Web Lords | C+ |
| Grow Extra Arms | Grow Extra Arms | C |
| Guy in the Chair | Eccentric Arachnologist | D+ |
| Kapow! | Perilous Lunge | B- |
| Kraven's Cats | Cruel Caracals | C |
| Kraven's Last Hunt | A Trail of Teacups | B+ |
| Lizard, Connors's Curse | King of the Coldblood Curse | A- |
| Lurking Lizards | Lurking Lizards | C- |
| Miles Morales // Ultimate Spider-Man | Cren, Undercity Dreamer | B+ |
| Pictures of Spider-Man | Ancestral Carvings | C |
| Professional Wrestler | Favored Fighter | C+ |
| Radioactive Spider | Fateweaver | B |
| Sandman, Shifting Scoundrel | The Scouring Stormsoul | A |
| Scout the City | Scout the City | C |
| Spider-Ham, Peter Porker | Tarantusk, Unwisely Awoken | B |
| Spider-Man, Brooklyn Visionary | Zan, Tunnelweb Explorer | C+ |
| Spider-Rex, Daring Dino | Chizak, Apex Arachnosaur | C |
| Spiders-Man, Heroic Horde | The Clutter Cluster | B |
| Strength of Will | Strength of Will | C |
| Supportive Parents | Supportive Parents | C+ |
| Terrific Team-Up | Terrific Team-Up | B |
| Wall Crawl | Rouse the Swarm | B- |
| Web of Life and Destiny | Through the Omenpath | B |
| Arachnogenesis* | Arachnogenesis | B+ |
| Arasta of the Endless Web* | Arasta of the Endless Web | B |
| Beast Within* | Beast Within | C- |
| Heroic Intervention* | Heroic Intervention | C |
| Hunter's Insight* | Hunter's Insight | C+ |
| Parallel Lives* | Parallel Lives | F |
| Silkguard* | Silkguard | C+ |
| Tangle* | Tangle | C |
| Artifact | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Bagel and Schmear | Perfected Pastry | C |
| Doc Ock's Tentacles | Giantcraft Helm | C |
| Eerie Gravestone | Eerie Gravestone | C |
| Hot Dog Cart | Treat Trolley | D+ |
| Interdimensional Web Watch | Reality Fulcrum | C+ |
| Iron Spider, Stark Upgrade | Fizik, Etherium Mechanic | C+ |
| Living Brain, Mechanical Marvel | Error-9, Viral Node | D- |
| Mechanical Mobster | Data Scrubber | C- |
| News Helicopter | Opulent Valet | C |
| Passenger Ferry | Carriage of Dreams | D |
| Peter Parker's Camera | Phenomena Recorder | F |
| Rocket-Powered Goblin Glider | Stitcher's Wings | C |
| Spider-Bot | Steelweb Surveyor | C- |
| Spider-Mobile | Scuttling Spidercoach | D+ |
| Spider-Slayer, Hatred Honed | Goro Rel, Scourge to Spiders | C+ |
| Spider-Suit | Cactarantula Saddle | D- |
| Steel Wrecking Ball | Temple Trap | D |
| Subway Train | Vinewoven Chariot | C- |
| Blue | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Amazing Acrobatics | Drix Interception | C+ |
| Beetle, Legacy Criminal | Arala, Hedron Scaler | C |
| Chameleon, Master of Disguise | Vazin, Two-Faced Trickster | C- |
| The Clone Saga | Lost in Littjara | C+ |
| Doc Ock, Sinister Scientist | Ozor, Chronicler of Collapse | C- |
| Doc Ock's Henchmen | Obscura Alleylurkers | D+ |
| Flying Octobot | Vexed Bots | B- |
| Hide on the Ceiling | Spectral Restitching | C |
| Hydro-Man, Fluid Felon | Belion, the Parched | C- |
| Impostor Syndrome | Impostor Syndrome | F |
| Lady Octopus, Inspired Inventor | Merata, Neuron Hacker | F |
| Madame Web, Clairvoyant | Olx, Mouth to Many Eyes | D- |
| Mysterio, Master of Illusion | The Watcher on the Road | B |
| Mysterio's Phantasm | Phantasmal Vision | B- |
| Norman Osborn // Green Goblin | Goben, Gene-Splice Savant | B+ |
| Oscorp Research Team | Pinnacle Research Team | D- |
| Robotics Mastery | Robotics Mastery | B- |
| School Daze | Outsmart the Amateur | C+ |
| Secret Identity | Secret Identity | D |
| Spider-Byte, Web Warden | Argyr, Tidal Spinner | B |
| Spider-Man No More | Hide in Mundanity | C |
| Spider-Sense | Detect Intrusion | D- |
| Unstable Experiment | Unstable Experiment | C+ |
| Whoosh! | Snatch Back | C+ |
| Clever Impersonator* | Clever Impersonator | B- |
| Counterspell* | Counterspell | C+ |
| Lorthos, the Tidemaker* | Lorthos, the Tidemaker | D+ |
| Mindbreak Trap* | Mindbreak Trap | D- |
| Mystic Confluence* | Mystic Confluence | A- |
| Ponder* | Ponder | C+ |
| Rite of Replication* | Rite of Replication | B |
| Traumatize* | Traumatize | F |
| Red | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Angry Rabble | Galvanized Workforce | C- |
| Electro, Assaulting Battery | Bayo, Irritable Instructor | C+ |
| Electro's Bolt | Deathflame Burst | C |
| Gwen Stacy // Ghost-Spider | Nia, Skysail Storyteller | B |
| Heroes' Hangout | Fire-Brained Scheme | D |
| Hobgoblin, Mantled Marauder | Cam and Farrik, Havoc Duo | C- |
| J. Jonah Jameson | Lazlo, Enthusiastic Accuser | C |
| Masked Meower | Skittering Kitten | D |
| Maximum Carnage | Lavabrink Repels the Magmaloth | F |
| Molten Man, Inferno Incarnate | The Infernus | C |
| Raging Goblinoids | Lavaborn Goblins | C+ |
| Romantic Rendezvous | Romantic Rendezvous | D+ |
| Shadow of the Goblin | Quint's Insight | B- |
| Shock | Kazuo, Ruthless Rival | C |
| Shocker, Unshakable | Wardens of Silverweb Summit | C |
| Spider-Gwen, Free Spirit | Sadistic String-Puller | D+ |
| Spider-Islanders | Kraza, the Swarm as One | C- |
| Spider-Punk | Arachnomania | C+ |
| Spider-Verse | Rizna, the Spider-Crowned | F |
| Spinneret and Spiderling | Kephon, Rage Incubator | D- |
| Stegron the Dinosaur Man | Restless Razorkin | C- |
| Superior Foes of Spider-Man | Full-Throttle Fanatic | C+ |
| Taxi Driver | Wisecrack | C- |
| Wisecrack | Goblin Bombardment | C+ |
| Goblin Bombardment* | Najeela, the Blade-Blossom | D |
| Najeela, the Blade-Blossom* | Relentless Assault | C |
| Relentless Assault* | Savage Beating | F |
| Savage Beating* | Shock | C |
| Thrill of Possibility* | Thrill of Possibility | C |
| Unexpected Windfall* | Unexpected Windfall | C- |
| Winds of Change* | Winds of Change | F |
| Multicolor | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Araña, Heart of the Spider | Gloria, the Great Armorer | B |
| Biorganic Carapace | Angler's Shield | B+ |
| Carnage, Crimson Chaos | Desecrex, Gift of Servitude | B |
| Cheering Crowd | Cheering Crowd | B |
| Cosmic Spider-Man | Scions of the Ur-Spider | B+ |
| Doctor Octopus, Master Planner | Neach, Pinnacle Pariah | B+ |
| Gallant Citizen | Gallant Citizen | B- |
| Green Goblin, Revenant | Nu and Sumi, Career Criminals | D |
| Jackal, Genius Geneticist | Druneth, Reviver of the Hive | F |
| Kraven, Proud Predator | Dreadfang, Loathed by Fans | C |
| Kraven the Hunter | Brako, Heartless Hunter | B |
| Mary Jane Watson | Demera, Soul of a Spider | B |
| Mister Negative | Withar, Cocoon Keeper | A- |
| Mob Lookout | Mob Lookout | C |
| Morbius the Living Vampire | Tearle, Entropic Hunger | B+ |
| Prowler, Clawed Thief | Carlo, Suave Schemer | B- |
| Pumpkin Bombardment | Knife Trick | C |
| Rhino, Barreling Brute | Xecau, Predation's Shadow | C |
| Rhino's Rampage | Rhino's Rampage | C+ |
| Scarlet Spider, Ben Reilly | Borys, the Spider Rider | B- |
| Scarlet Spider, Kaine | Kivni, Orb Weaver | C- |
| Shriek, Treblemaker | Crash, Reckless Endrider | C |
| Silk, Web Weaver | Alenni, Brood Recruiter | A |
| Skyward Spider | Wonderweave Aerialist | C+ |
| SP//dr, Piloted by Peni | Kumonosu, the Watchful | B |
| Spider Manifestation | Leyline Weaver | B- |
| Spider-Girl, Legacy Hero | Janai and Hoppy, Roofskippers | B |
| Spider-Man 2099 | Uharis, the Stormspinner | C- |
| Spider-Man India | Alessos and Pras, Acrobats | B |
| Spider-Woman, Stunning Savior | Makdee and Itla, Skysnarers | B+ |
| The Spot, Living Portal | Qoneus, Horizon Splicer | A |
| Sun-Spider, Nimble Webber | Cirina Bargainspinner | B |
| Superior Spider-Man | Kavaero, Mind-Bitten | C+ |
| Symbiote Spider-Man | Skv'x the Augmenter | B+ |
| Ultimate Green Goblin | Ruzic, Booed but Victorious | B- |
| Vulture, Scheming Scavenger | Rishei, Getaway Accomplice | D+ |
| Web-Warriors | Diligent Webkeepers | C+ |
| Wraith, Vicious Vigilante | Margot, On the Case | D+ |
| Alibou, Ancient Witness* | Alibou, Ancient Witness | C+ |
| Terminate* | Terminate | B |
| Land | OM1 | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Daily Bugle Building | Fearsome Ridgeline | C- |
| Multiversal Passage | Multiversal Passage | C+ |
| Ominous Asylum | Ominous Asylum | C+ |
| Oscorp Industries | Exclusive Nightclub | C+ |
| Savage Mansion | Savage Mansion | C+ |
| Sinister Hideout | Sinister Hideout | C+ |
| Suburban Sanctuary | Suburban Sanctuary | C+ |
| University Campus | University Campus | C+ |
| Urban Retreat | Urban Retreat | C+ |
| Vibrant Cityscape | Vibrant Cityscape | C+ |
*You wont see these cards that often, as they aren’t from the main set, but only appear on the bonus sheet.
Conclusion
That’s it for today! Now you know how good each card should be in this new draft format. Do you disagree with our opinions? Want to know the reasoning behind specific grades? Let us know in the comments below and we’ll can discuss them in more detail.
Want to organize a draft for your play group? If so, you’re going to need a Spider-Man Play booster box, which you can already order on Amazon.
Until next time, enjoy Magic and good luck with your drafts! Remember: with great picks comes great victory.